I do not want to talk about guns or gun control.
I am not planning to discuss my opinions, fears, concerns, or beliefs regarding firearms and the laws which govern their use and possession.
I am not interested in any of that, and I am not alone. Almost everyone has complete lack of interest in having a real discussion about guns or gun laws or any related subjects.
This must certainly seem strange, since it only takes a few minutes on Facebook, or looking through the opinion pages, to find an article, rant, or study being employed to make a point about guns. There is no shortage of stories dedicated to crimes committed by guns. It would seem that people are constantly engaged in the so-called "gun debate."
Only, there is no such thing.
There is no debate about guns, or ammunition, or gun laws, or the constitution. Rather, there is an emotionally charged screaming match, pitting supposed patriots against supposedly concerned mothers, and self taught constitutional scholars against self appointed moral arbiters.
Just wait for
the next mass shooting spree to take place - they are sadly very common in the US, but when it inevitably happens, you'll see what I mean. Within minutes of hearing the horrific news of another act of violence, which will undoubtedly leave several people dead and several more injured, the non-debate will begin. In news outlets both "
conservative" and "
liberal," pundits will rush forward to pontificate from behind their teleprompters. On social media. people you know will post articles and statistics and even their opinions, often in
ALL CAPS. It won't be difficult, in either case, to pick up on a few key points.
The first is that people who are opposed to gun ownership or favor gun control, no matter how modest, are opposed to freedom. Those people, you will learn, are
against our nations very own constitution. In fact, you'll soon find that anyone who proposes any kind of gun control at all is, in fact,
a Nazi! You may even come to realize that gun ownership, far from being just a right, is actually something that
should be mandatory!
On the other hand, you may encounter people that want to
ban a lot of guns altogether, not just for criminals, but for everyone. Typically, most people will share articles that seem more sensible, though these will almost always be about
children and guns. Other opinion pieces will go much further, and you'll learn that responsible gun ownership
simply does not exist.
Both sides in this "discussion" will appeal to your fear that your kids will be shot, that Hitler is writing gun control legislation in a bunker beneath the White House, or that some shadowy organization is plotting against whichever side you happen to identify with.
That is not a debate.
In my experience, based on the things I see people post online or what I hear them say in person, is that after one of these shootings takes place, people go from 0 to 60 in about half a second. They are so emotional, they become unable to make an argument that doesn't involve concentration camps or dead babies. As soon as the subject is introduced, people become completely unable to have a reasonable discussion of any kind.
Think there should be licences to own firearms? You hate freedom. Think that people with a clean record should be able to own an AR-15? You're a nut-job. There is name calling, yelling, paranoia, finger pointing and assignment of blame.
However, there is no debate.
I don't pretend to have answers to the problems that surround this non discussion. I suppose I could try to think of ways to have a real discussion about this. I could try to share facts regarding how these kinds of mass killings, which are the emotionally charged gun events we are the most aware of, make up
only a portion of the
overall number of those killed. I could also point out that while we are all screaming at each other about a classroom full of dead children in a small town, there are actually
other victims of gun crime who receive far less attention in our make-believe discourse. Maybe we could talk about pressure groups and
the role they play.
I really don't have much of a dog in this fight. I don't own guns, nor have I been affected by gun crime. I am certainly concerned when people die needlessly, but I am not convinced that there is an easy way to legislate the problem into oblivion.
We are long overdue for a debate, of that there is no question. We need to have the discussion about these issues. We need to solve some of these problems. But, we need to stop fooling ourselves. There is no debate, there has been no debate, and when the same story about a mass shooting is presented to us yet again, there will still not be one.